Subtle Supernatural Elements Writing Prompts

Dating a telepath has had its quirks. You cruised through the first phase of your relationship, arguments end in a flash, but most strange of all is how they know you are aroused before you even do

Your girlfriend is actually a eldritch horror. The tentacles are good and all but she has to suppress her innate reality warping and sanity breaking abilities but she looses control when she reaches climax.

Werewolves are famously known for being brutal, savage and intensely hot blooded. It turns out they're the complete opposite when mating, becoming gentle, affectionate, and extremely loving, especially with Human mates

You never expected Sleep Paralysis Demons to be real, let alone that they're actually just touch-starved succubi/incubi who mostly just want to cuddle.

Pair of twin sisters share a strange connection, they have each other's pussies. They each experience no sensations from the vagina attached to their bodies, instead, feeling what happens to their sister's as if it were their own.

Invisible spirit-like creatures are a completely normal thing. They tend to use humans a sexual play things, whenever and wherever they want. The more attractive you are the more likey a spirit will spend its time around you.

Taking a job out of town, the place looks weird. Whatever, it's retail. Slowly you realise the customers are a little on the... supernatural side. And they seem to watch you during the moments your mind goes a little nsfw. It takes one specific day to realise they can read your mind... vividly.

For better or worse, you have the tendency to stumble upon the supernatural. Your best friend, a protector of the mystics, and his nemesis are constantly perplexed at how you manage to get yourself involved without even trying.

You suspect your new partner might not be what they claimed to be. Yesterday you asked them to change the lightbulb and they said "Sure, into what?" You want the truth but not a confrontation.

Your wife is gorgeous, cute, and everything you want in a woman. Except for the curse. Every time you slide your cock into her, she transforms into another woman you know. All you want is to make love to the lady who teases you all day.

Some children will draw terrifying shadow monsters sometimes. You are a kindergartener who has to explain to the teacher that the shadow monster you drew in your family photo really is part of your family and not something you made up.

Every time your rich friend comes back from vacation, he talks in weird slang. Over the last 10 years, you have come to suspect that he is actually a time traveler.

I have no idea why this relaxation app is titled "Become Sluttier," she said, as she undid a button on her top, casually browsing for new red lipstick on her phone. "It is great chill out music though," she said, as she thought about masturbating to *really* help relax...

While on a camping trip you snuck away to masterbate. Once you've finished you see that the clearing you're in has almost purposefully arranged stones that you've gotten your seed on, and the whole clearing is surrounded by mushrooms.

You were target of mischief by unnatural entity disguised as a human but, talking with the individual for a while. Individual is actually pretty nice and, does have some things in common with you.

One of the weirdest things about being in a sorority with ghosts is when your sisters need to "borrow" your body...

He was thrilled to have a succubus wife and a house full of half succubus daughters, but things could get more than a little "unconventional" at times...

You are a night shift manager at a grocery store. You’ve started to notice that all of the people you have hired may not be humans at all.

A shapeshifter finds herself working late at the office with her coworker, a regular human dude. He is oblivious to her bottled sexual frustration.

Your first date is going well; the banter is great and the smiles are genuine. But you’re starting to suspect your date really is over a thousand years old.

“Oh, guys look a shooting star!” Me and all my other friends were out camping when I pointed it out. “Um… what should I wish for… ohh I dunno… how about you all wish for me?”

People constantly mistake the really buff lady at the gym for a man. Doesn't help that she's a werewolf.

A Sorcerer has cast a spell to activate every magic symbol in the world. Suddenly tattoos of magic symbols start glowing on people.

After years of no luck, you finally got yourself a girlfriend! Your sleep paralysis demon isn't happy about that.

Your imaginary friend has returned and hopes to become an imaginary friend with benefits

Reality is changed, and women's breasts now have RPG Levels, with leveling up causing them to grow larger. But the weirdest thing is you seem to be the only one to notice the the growth as it happens, and the only one able to see and interact with the UI and apply earned perks.

“Go touch some grass bro!” … “The grass…the grass touched me…”

“So,” rasped the thing under your bed as it pulled itself out into the room again, “have you told your mom about us yet?”

A sleazy womanizer tells tall tales to women at bars to sleep with him. He has a reputation of being a serial liar. One night, a woman the he had slept with enters the bar and curses him so that he can't tell a lie. After she leaves, the man doesn't feel any different. Hilarity ensues.

The one male intern at the office suddenly develops an irresistible personality. How does he use it to his advantage?